Why are Teslas more expensive to insure than other cars?

Tesla cars are known for their sleek design, high performance, and advanced technology. But they also come with a higher price tag than most other vehicles, both in terms of purchase and insurance costs. According to NerdWallet, the average cost of Tesla car insurance is $2,503 per year for a 2021 Tesla Model 3, which is about 45% higher than the national average for car insurance. Why are Teslas more expensive to insure than other cars, and what can you do to lower your insurance premiums? Here are some factors that affect the cost of Tesla car insurance and some tips to save money.

Factors that increase the cost of Tesla car insurance

  • Repair costs: Tesla cars are made with specialized parts and materials that are not widely available or easy to replace. For example, Tesla uses aluminum for its body panels, which requires special tools and skills to repair. Tesla also has a limited network of authorized repair shops, which means that you may have to wait longer or pay more for repairs. Additionally, Tesla cars have advanced features like the battery pack, the touchscreen, and the Autopilot system, which can be expensive to fix or replace if damaged. All these factors make Tesla cars more costly to repair than average cars, which increases the risk for insurance companies and leads to higher premiums.
  • Theft rates: Tesla cars are attractive targets for thieves because of their high value and popularity. According to the Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI), Tesla Model S and Model X have higher theft claim rates than other large luxury cars. Tesla Model 3 also has a higher theft claim rate than other midsize luxury cars. Although Tesla has introduced some security features like Sentry Mode and PIN to Drive to deter thefts, they may not be enough to prevent them entirely. Higher theft rates mean higher insurance costs for Tesla owners.
  • Performance: Tesla cars are known for their impressive acceleration and speed, which can tempt drivers to drive more aggressively or recklessly. According to HLDI, Tesla Model S and Model X have higher collision claim rates than other large luxury cars. Tesla Model 3 also has a higher collision claim rate than other midsize luxury cars. Collision claims are one of the most common and expensive types of claims for insurance companies, which means that they charge more for cars that are more likely to be involved in collisions.

Tips to lower the cost of Tesla car insurance

  • Shop around: Different insurance companies may offer different rates for Tesla cars, depending on their risk assessment and underwriting criteria. It is important to compare quotes from multiple insurers before choosing a policy. You can use online tools like NerdWallet’s car insurance comparison tool or Insurance.com’s auto insurance quote tool to find the best deal for your Tesla car.
  • Choose a higher deductible: A deductible is the amount of money that you have to pay out of pocket before your insurance company pays for a claim. Choosing a higher deductible can lower your premium, as it means that you are willing to share more of the risk with your insurer. However, you should make sure that you can afford to pay the deductible in case of an accident.
  • Take advantage of discounts: Many insurance companies offer discounts for various factors that can reduce your risk or improve your driving behavior. For example, you may qualify for discounts if you have a clean driving record, take a defensive driving course, install anti-theft devices, bundle your policies, pay your premium in full, or enroll in a usage-based program. You should ask your insurer about the discounts that they offer and see if you are eligible for any of them.
  • Consider Tesla Insurance: If you live in one of the 11 states where Tesla offers its own insurance program, you may want to consider it as an option. Tesla claims that its insurance is competitively priced and reflects the safety and technology features of its vehicles. Tesla also says that it understands its vehicles better than traditional insurers and can provide faster and more convenient claims service. However, you should still compare Tesla’s rates with other insurers before making a decision.

Other reasons why Teslas are expensive to insure include:

  • They are seen as being more risky to insure.
  • They are more likely to be involved in accidents due to their advanced features.
  • They are very fast.
  • Even the tiniest of knocks will dent an expensive and complicated panel rather than a deformable piece of plastic.
  • Some parts to repair it are in short supply.

The average annual premium for a Tesla Model 3 is: 2022: $2,086, 2021: $2,102, 2020: $2,137, 2019: $1,928.


Tesla cars are more expensive to insure than other cars because of their high repair costs, theft rates, and performance. However, there are ways to lower your insurance premiums, such as shopping around, choosing a higher deductible, taking advantage of discounts, or considering Tesla Insurance. By following these tips, you may be able to save money on your Tesla car insurance and enjoy the benefits of owning a cutting-edge vehicle.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What are some other factors that affect car insurance rates?

Several factors influence car insurance rates, not just the make and model of your vehicle. Some key factors include:

1. Driving History: Your personal driving history, including accidents and traffic violations, significantly affects your insurance rates. A clean record often leads to lower premiums.
2. Location: Where you live can impact your rates. Urban areas with higher rates of accidents and theft may result in higher premiums.
3. Age and Gender: Younger and less experienced drivers tend to have higher insurance rates. Additionally, some insurers consider gender when calculating rates.
4. Coverage Options: The level of coverage you choose, including deductibles and limits, will affect your premiums.
5. Credit Score: In some states, your credit score can be a factor in determining insurance rates.
6. Vehicle Usage: How you use your car (e.g., for commuting, business, or pleasure) can influence rates.
7. Safety Features: Vehicles equipped with advanced safety features may be eligible for discounts.

How do I know if my Tesla is eligible for discounts?

To determine if your Tesla is eligible for insurance discounts, you can take the following steps:

1. Contact Your Insurer: Reach out to your insurance provider and inquire about any discounts specific to Teslas or electric vehicles.
2. Research Discounts: Research insurance companies that specialize in electric vehicle coverage, as they may offer unique discounts for Tesla owners.
3. Safety Features: Highlight the safety features of your Tesla, such as autopilot, advanced driver-assistance systems, and collision avoidance technology, which can make you eligible for discounts.
4. Safe Driving Habits: Some insurers offer discounts for drivers who consistently practice safe driving habits while using the vehicle’s advanced features.

Why are Tesla’s so much more expensive?

Tesla vehicles tend to be more expensive for several reasons:

1. Advanced Technology: Teslas feature cutting-edge electric vehicle technology, including high-performance electric motors and extensive battery systems, which can drive up manufacturing costs.
2. Luxury Brand: Tesla is considered a premium electric vehicle brand, and the luxury segment typically commands higher price points.
3. Innovative Features: Teslas come equipped with innovative features, such as Autopilot and over-the-air updates, which add to their price.
4. Limited Production: As of my last knowledge update in September 2021, Tesla’s production capacity was limited compared to traditional automakers, which can affect economies of scale.
5. High Demand: High demand for Tesla vehicles allows the company to maintain premium pricing.

What is the most expensive Tesla to insure?

The insurance cost for Teslas can vary based on factors like the specific model, your location, and your personal driving record. Generally, the most expensive Tesla models to insure are the high-performance and luxury variants. As of my last knowledge update, the Tesla Model S Performance and the Model X Performance, which come with powerful electric motors and advanced features, tend to have higher insurance premiums compared to the standard models. However, these rates can change over time, so it’s essential to obtain insurance quotes for your specific Tesla model.

Why is Tesla better than other cars?

Whether a Tesla is better than other cars depends on individual preferences and needs. Tesla vehicles offer several advantages that may make them appealing to some:

1. Electric Power: Teslas run on electricity, producing zero tailpipe emissions and reducing the carbon footprint.
2. High Performance: Many Tesla models offer impressive acceleration and handling due to their electric drivetrains.
3. Advanced Technology: Teslas come equipped with cutting-edge technology, including Autopilot for semi-autonomous driving and over-the-air updates.
4. Long Range: Tesla’s electric vehicles often have longer driving ranges compared to some other electric cars.
5. Charging Infrastructure: Tesla has an extensive Supercharger network, making long-distance travel more convenient.

However, whether Tesla is better than other cars ultimately depends on your priorities, budget, and specific driving needs. It’s crucial to compare different makes and models to determine what suits you best.

Leave a comment